Home

About Us

Books

E-Mail Groups

Letters To Loved Ones

Links

Newsletter Archives

Spouses & Partners

What Is Trans?

A BROTHER LEARNS TO ACCEPT HIS NEW BROTHER

Letter emailed to my parents and my brother, 12/23/99

(Folks,)

Attached, please find some of my newest pictures, taken November 29, 1999. The pictures of me in a tie are from February 21, 1999. I like them! I'm a handsome guy, and look much more like my brother than I ever did! But I'm cuter, ask any of my friends! LOL The bird is Beasley, and the dog is Oden, one of my roommate's. He's a 5 year old Boxer/Mastiff mix that is a real hoot! A GREAT boy!

If any of you would like any prints, please just let me know which ones...each file has a specific label.

Please know that I am happier than I've ever been. I am consistently seen as 8-10 years younger than my chronological age, simply because of the peace of mind of being me now. I'm working harder on lots of stuff to be better able to take care of myself and I have already made great progress. Right now I'm taking a short therapy break...a good time for it; I was getting stuck, and my therapist is in need of serious back surgery. I am no longer a totally dependent victim needing to be taken care of. There are lots of things about life that I am seeing and learning about, and it's kind of neat to be where I am at this point. Like a kid seeing things for the first time, and with the same sense of excitement sometimes. Sometimes kind of scary too, but not in the old way. I am not running away from life now. I am living, experiencing, and feeling life now, and it's good...VERY good. My transition has not solved all my problems, I was never under the illusion that it would. But it has enabled me to tap into an inner strength that others figured was always there, but was totally hidden from me. Now I know why. There are many things I am having to learn, about being a man, but also being a person. It is exciting!

Our expressions of our faith in God are very different, but many people have told me that hearing my life-story it is very obviously a God-driven journey. Throughout most of the first part of it all, culminating 3 years ago in January in the hospital, everything that has happened to me and with me since has been eerily non-coincidental. The people placed in my life, the situations, the opportunities, the experiences....all have made total sense to me at every turn. I have been very blessed to have been spared a lot of the turmoil that so many transfolk have had to endure, and also have been spared the difficult "in-between" place inherent in this journey. I was able to become who you see in the pictures with little trouble, being seen as male from the beginning. It is another indication that God knew what he was doing!

I see only good things ahead. Maybe not where any of us had envisioned life for me, but certainly incredibly different from what we had been seeing in my future for the last few decades (ouch...that makes all of us feel too old...sorry :~} ) I may never get all that far in life. But I have already had to journey farther than many people. Finally I am able to enjoy where I am.

I understand that this has been a difficult journey for all of you. I don't know whether it was easier or harder being so distant from each other. But none of you are alone in your feelings or reactions. Every transperson has family in some respect, be it biological, or chosen. Some are able to maintain good relationships with their families, some are not. Some families are actively supportive during transition, some are quietly supportive, some are negative, some have chosen to deny the existence altogether of their relative. Our family has been fractured for many, many years. Sometimes with the splinters very sharp and painful. Things have happened, and some of them will never be able to be healed. That is something painful, but sometimes necessary. But I have appreciated the attempts to accept and understand who I am and my journey to become me. Hopefully, that can expand to include meeting me. I really can be a fun guy to know!

I have some people in my life that are parents of transman, and gay transmen at that. They have offered to converse with any of you at any time, and can steer you to resources and support nearby if you would like. Just let me know. Kitten Gross, from Cleveland, especially, whom I met last winter in Maryland is a real peach. She and her husband Bob are active in PFLAG (Parents, Family, Friends and Allies of Lesbians and Gays) and founded TransFamily of Cleveland. They have many members, and meet every month for a potluck dinner and discussions. They have an email list I am on. I also have a book edited by another woman that I met in Maryland at the conference. It is a compilation of stories by relatives of transfolk. I bought a copy for myself, one to loan out to friends, one for the mom of a friend of mine, and one to send up for the 3 of you. It really is a neat book. Kitten and Bob Gross wrote about Mitch, who was one of my first buddies online, and the first transman I ever met in person.

I hope that this Christmas, the last of the century, can be the best one of the century. It sure is for me!

Gonna close this now, I can't believe I actually wrote a letter!

Merry Christmas, and Happy New Year!

Joshua

PS: Please share me with the friends that know me, I think they'd be pleasantly surprised, and happy that I have finally found ME! I still am your child, just a new and much improved model!


Response that same day, 12/23/99 from my brother:

Joshua:

We all build a "life resume" that includes places we have seen, people we have met, and things which we have accomplished. Some days are more important or meaningful than others and some events, though possibly small in themselves, act as punctuation for larger ongoing changes or events. I think your email letter is an example of punctuation deserving of a mention on your life resume. I am very proud of you and the articulate way you expressed yourself in your letter. To me, it represents years of effort to find yourself and to understand and organize your past. The letter is very "adult". Congratulations.

I have always been glad that I have a sibling and am reasonably indifferent as to gender and/or sexual orientation. I confess to getting mixed up with the pronouns at times but that reflects the fact that you were my sister for most of my life and I am unwilling to take the possibly more expedient approach of dealing with "Deb" and "Joshua" as two different people. To me you have always been, and always will be, my sibling. I have only had one, whether male or female. Unfortunately, the English language has gender-biased elements (imagine the problems of the French!). Sibling is an unworkable word and old habits die hard. Don't let occasional wired in speech patterns undercut your sense for how supportive I am. You are my brother and I value your choice.

Most people live as the sex they were born, in the religion to which they were born, and, frequently, to the expectations to which they were subjected. You have chosen your sex and your religion, now is when you can cast off your ingrained perceptions of what you think our (your family's) expectations are or were and choose new ones that suit you. We probably have fewer expectations than you might think! Based on your having chosen your sex and religion, perhaps you are best suited for a career as a professional "convert" (unfortunately it probably doesn't pay very well).

On a more serious note, it is hard to do what you have done. Society, as a whole, has not yet learned to deal with the legitimate needs of large segments of the population, including yours. What you have done probably requires BOTH courage AND extraordinary motivation. People don't choose to change their sex as the "easy way out". I can't imagine what could me a harder choice in today's world. The motivation, as you know only too well, borders on desperation. I can't imagine anything worse than trying to live as someone you are not. I had to borrow clothes from Joe down in Florida one time and it made me extremely uncomfortable because the clothes did not mirror who I am. I get extremely uncomfortable when people try to categorize me (usually incorrectly) as a republican or some other affiliation. I am who I am. I just happen, for the most part, to be what society expects me to be. If I weren't, there would be hell to pay!

I am also proud of the way Mom and Dad have each worked to come to grips with the issues. They were born in a different world than you and I. Having children has taught me a lot of things I didn't know. No person can ever have the same perspective on a person as that person's parents. No other relationship is the same (for better or worse). No amount of love, no level of involvement, nothing. The parent/child relationship is unique. Some work better than others, but they are all still unique compared with any other type of relationship. The shared genes and nature's most basic instincts get combined with all a parent's hopes and dreams.

When Mom and Dad look at you or me they know that we mean more to them than they do to us. It's how nature structures life. My children take me for granted and I want them to. I, on the other hand, view them as the center of my universe. And that is the way it's supposed to work. When Mom and Dad look at you they still see the tiny baby at the very start of life. It was yesterday to them but a lifetime ago for you. They try harder than you realize and they care more than you realize. Any mistakes they made were when they were younger than you and I are now in what has become through time a vague and unreal haze. What is still in sharp focus for them are the images that they locked in their mind's eye. Things like watching you up on stage playing the clarinet or the look on your face when you first rode a bicycle. At the time they may or may not have said or done the right thing or the thing you wanted or needed, but those are the images they carry around.

Don't ever let your family (any of us) stop you from being who you are or who you want to be. On the other hand, don't ever underestimate the value of family. Develop the relationship with each family member individually and also the family as a whole. Even as a 43 year old "adult" I take for granted that I can call and talk to Mom or Dad. I cannot imagine either of them not being there. Odds are reasonably high that at some point (I hope distant) I will have the opportunity to see what it feels like to know that, no matter how much I want to, I can't ever talk to them again. It is a sobering thought. What Mary Lou would give for a chance to talk to her Father for five minutes just one more time!

I haven't been as accessible over the past couple of months as I would have liked to have been. I narrowed my focus for a while to the children and to work with a little left over for my marriage and my goddaughter. It was a temporary necessity which is now completed. I look forward to the new millennium with my wife, my children, my parents and my brother (and the gazillion members of my extended family).

(signed)

TransFamily is provided as a service of Pro-Motion Internet Design a division of Pro-Motion Video and Global Graphics Internet Design. Website design ©® by Rick Cordaro for Global Graphics Internet Design. Original content and design © copyright TransFamily, all rights reserved.